This is a special edition of NNAAC’s Federal Policy Roundup. The federal government has proposed changes to the 2030 Census that would erase millions of people from the national count, among them Arab Americans, immigrants, and communities of color. Public comments are open through November 2, and your voice is needed now.
Census Update: Proposed Changes Would Remove Millions of People From the National Count
The Census Bureau has proposed these changes, not finalized them. It cannot adopt them until it collects public comments and considers what people say. That period ends November 2, 2026. No one at the Bureau is elected, so a comment is the only direct say the public has in what this rule becomes. Comments are filed on the public record, and you can send one in a few clicks below.
Send a ready-made comment in a few clicks and tailor it if you like, using either our general comment on the rule or the issue you care about most: Small Businesses, Education, Health Care, Arts & Culture, or Civil Rights. Each one is filed for you with the Census Bureau, under your name or anonymously. If you are writing on behalf of an organization, we have a template for that as well.
We also put together a flowchart showing what the rule would change and who it would affect. You can also scroll down to learn more details.
The Proposed Changes Would:
- Remove all race and ethnicity questions.
- Implement new residence rules that require the government to determine everyone’s immigration status and count only U.S. citizens and green card holders toward each state’s seats in Congress.
- Implement new residence rules that change how the census decides where you live.
What Could This Mean for Our Communities?
When people aren’t counted accurately, communities can lose resources and opportunities for an entire decade. These proposed changes would impact everyone, especially communities with large immigrant, minority, and low-income households.
Less Funding for Schools
Census data helps determine funding for public schools and educational programs. If families are undercounted, schools may receive fewer resources even though the same number of students still show up every day.
This can mean:
- Larger class sizes.
- Fewer teachers, counselors, and support staff.
- Less funding for after-school programs.
- Reduced language access services for multilingual families.
- Fewer resources for school meals and student support programs.
Fewer Resources for Health Care
Hospitals, community health centers, and public health agencies use census data to understand who lives in a community and what services are needed. Census data is also used in formulas that help determine how federal funding is distributed to states for programs such as Medicaid and other public benefit programs. When communities are undercounted, states may receive fewer resources to meet the needs of the people who actually live there.
For example, if a community has high rates of diabetes, heart disease, or certain genetic conditions but is not accurately counted, healthcare systems may not receive the information needed to plan services or secure funding to address those needs. Similarly, if a state’s population is undercounted, federal funding formulas may not fully reflect the number of people who rely on healthcare and public benefits, creating additional strain on local providers and services.
In short, when the census misses people, it can mean fewer healthcare resources, longer wait times, reduced services, and less support for the programs that many families depend on every day.
Less Investment in Roads, Transportation, and Infrastructure
Population data helps governments plan for growth and invest in transportation and infrastructure projects. When communities are undercounted, infrastructure funding may go elsewhere even when local needs continue to grow.
Reduced Support for Community Services
Many nonprofit organizations and community programs use census data to demonstrate need and compete for funding. When the data suggests fewer people need services than how many actually do, organizations often have a harder time securing resources for the communities they serve.
This can affect:
- Senior services
- Youth programs
- Workforce development initiatives
- Food assistance programs
- Housing and homelessness services
- Domestic violence and family support programs
Less Accurate Representation of Our Communities
Census data helps decision makers understand who lives in a community, what challenges they face, and where resources should go.
Without accurate information:
- Communities can become invisible in government planning.
- Elected officials have less information about constituent needs.
- Advocates have fewer tools to demonstrate disparities.
- It becomes harder to address discrimination and inequities.
For Arab Americans, this is especially significant. After years of advocacy, the 2030 Census was expected to be the first census that included a Middle Eastern or North African (MENA) category. Removing race and ethnicity questions would mean losing the opportunity to finally be counted and recognized in federal data. For many of us, this is not just about data. It is about being seen. If communities are not reflected in the data, it becomes harder to demonstrate our needs, advocate for resources, and ensure decision-makers understand who we are.
Impact on Civil Rights
Accurate and detailed census data is an important tool for protecting civil rights. Government agencies, courts, researchers, and advocates use population data to identify disparities, assess whether communities are being treated fairly, and enforce protections against discrimination.
Changes to the census could make it harder to:
- Identify unequal access to voting, education, housing, employment, and health care.
- Draw fair and representative voting districts.
- Provide appropriate language assistance.
- Document discrimination affecting Arab American and other historically undercounted communities.
Why Immigration Status Matters
The proposal could discourage participation among households with noncitizens and naturalized citizens. Many families may worry about how information could be used, even though census responses are confidential.
This can affect:
- Whether people participate in the census.
- Whether households include all members on their census forms.
- Whether predominantly Black and Brown communities are accurately counted.
- The resources available to schools, hospitals, local governments, and community organizations.
An undercount does not just affect immigrants. When fewer people are counted, entire neighborhoods can lose resources and services based on population data.